Community Relations

Moving Beyond Suburban Sprawl & Big-Box Development in Ogden, Utah

High density mixed-use development provides cities with the greatest return per acre in property tax revenue. And the numbers confirm that premise.

|


OGDEN Land use decisions directly affect a city’s long term fiscal health.

Such is the core belief of Strong Towns, a nonprofit advocacy organization that aims to replace the decades-old mindset of suburban sprawl and big-box development with something more sustainable.

As Strong Towns sees it, high density mixed-use development provides cities with the greatest return per acre in property tax revenue. And the numbers confirm that premise.

The 220,000 square foot Walmart built on 34 acres had a taxable value of $20 million. Its per-acre tax bill came to $6,500

The taxable value of the downtown 54,000 square foot building on .19 acre came to $11 million with a corresponding tax bill of $634,000 per acre. 

“This is not important because we love multistory buildings or density. It doesn’t have anything to do with aesthetics,” Strong Towns Program Director Rachel Quednau said in her 2017 article. “Rather, it’s important because that simple six-story building uses just a few dozen yards of street and sidewalk and pipe while generating tons of revenue for the city.”

In contrast, Quednau noted that Walmart’s massive use of public infrastructure places ongoing demands on the city’s budget.

While Strong Towns and Urban3 might not be the final word on community planning and growth, municipal development staff are heeding their findings.

The Ogden Walmart on Wall Avenue. Another generic big-box store.

Balanced approach

In 2017, Ogden’s Community and Economic Development team asked Urban3 to determine where the city’s highest and most valuable property was located. It turned out to be the city’s compact and dense downtown.

Brandon Cooper, Ogden CED Director, said that Urban3’s conclusion was “one of the things we’ve really doubled down on.”

“Our job was to return services back to the community as a result of their tax payment,” Cooper said, adding that, “we can’t just continue to tax people into prosperity.”

The Ogden Walmart at 1959 Wall Avenue, built in 2010, consists of a 147,560 square foot structure on 15.6 acres. Valued at $11,652,000, its 2022 tax bill came to $146,303 or $9,360 per acre.

We compared it to the south side of the lower block of Historic 25th Street, where structures reach three stories and fit snugly side by side.

Some buildings date back to 1887, while the newest were constructed by 2005. When combined, those 13 properties cover just over one acre (1.06), with structures adding up to 44,213 square feet and a total taxable value of $5,743,601. Their 2022 tax bills came to $68,201 or $64,341 per acre.

The downtown Tower View Apartments, built in 2016, offer another interesting comparison to Walmart. Built on 1.58 acres, the three-story 305,444 square foot structure at 2276 Washington Blvd. has a taxable value of $30.4 million. Its 2022 tax bill came to $212,264 or $134,345 per acre.

These are compelling figures, but for a city that stretches across several unique neighborhoods and districts, Cooper sees the need to take more factors into account when it comes to community planning.

For example, property tax falls into two categories: real and personal. The larger buildings at Business Depot Ogden might yield lower per-acre tax value, but some might also house expensive machines that yield significant personal property tax revenue. 

“So all of that is taxed and comes to the benefit of the city,” Cooper said.

But Strong Towns and Urban3 continue to influence development in and around the city’s core.

A few blocks east of downtown, the long-vacant lot at 24th Street and Monroe Boulevard once the home to an IGA grocery and Rite-Aid drug store is finally slated for mixed-use development that should launch in early 2023.

“It will have a smaller grocery store, and some smaller retail … and it will largely be residential housing,” Cooper said, describing it as a microcosm of developing the balance needed to achieve sustainability.

Megan Townsend, Community and Economic Director for the Wasatch Front Regional Council, provided a multi-county perspective.

“As a general principle, it’s very wise for a city to look at the bottom line and plan for both quality of life and fiscal sustainability,” Townsend said in support of Strong Towns and Urban3 models especially for core downtowns and surrounding neighborhoods.

But she cautioned against a one-size-fits-all approach, saying that planners must also take into account  a city’s existing conditions, fiscal needs and the things that make it unique.

“Diving into the weeds for every neighborhood is really important,” Townsend said.

RELATED CONTENT

The Fate of Ogden’s Union Station

A New Several Stories High Apartment Building on Historic 25th Street in Ogden, Utah Ruining Its Charm or Not? Residents Complain.

Vanishing Farmland: Paradise Lost as Vital Farmland Gives Way to Development in Ogden Valley, Utah

More Development Projects Coming to Ogden

Trouble in Paradise: Ogden Valley Considers Its Water Use Future

SUPPORT LOCAL JOURNALISM AND SUBSCRIBE TO PRINT MAGAZINE

 

Subscribe to Utah Stories weekly newsletter and get our stories directly to your inbox

* indicates required



 

, , ,


Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.


  • A Ski Village or a Tipping Point? Nordic Valley Expansion Divides Ogden Valley

    The project, known as Nordic Village, is expected to roll out over the next decade and represents one of the largest tourism developments in the valley’s history.


  • Utah Official’s $36K Travel Reimbursements Raise Questions About Use of Taxpayer Funds

    The trek into the office is a necessary evil for many employees; unpaid time that could be spent elsewhere. But some state employees are able to cash in on their commutes.

    That includes one member of Gov. Spencer Cox’s cabinet who heads the Utah Department of Cultural & Community Engagement. The department oversees a number of civic and social programs ranging from museums, libraries and the state historical society, to volunteerism efforts and multicultural affairs. 

    The employee’s in-state travel expenses made up a large chunk of the department’s employee reimbursements in recent years, according to documents obtained by The Utah Investigative Journalism Project obtained through a public records request. 

    The UIJP reviewed spreadsheets detailing the reimbursed expenses of the department’s 17-person leadership team over the 2024 and 2025 fiscal years. 

    The analysis showed one employee, Executive Director Donna Law, accounted for nearly a third of the team’s reimbursements in 2024 and 43% in 2025. Law, who lives in Cedar City, spent more than 11 times the average amount spent by all other employees included in the analysis. 

    The majority of Law’s expenses were categorized as in-state travel, which includes mileage and lodging. Between the two years, she spent $21,607.94 on lodging, $10,135.42  on auto mileage, and $1,455.00 in miscellaneous travel expenses and meals for a total of over $33,000. 

    The next highest amount spent on in-state travel was $3,385. Law’s overall spending far exceeded any other employee.

    The nearly $36,000 Law spent on travel and other items wasnearly three times that spent by the employee with the second highest amount in reimbursements. His expenses, in contrast, were largely out-of-state travel.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • The $7 Million Recruit: How NIL Changed College Athletics Forever

    In 2012, Jabari Parker, a top high school prospect and member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, was facing his biggest decision to that point in his life: where to play college basketball. 

    Fans of BYU athletics hoped and perhaps prayed that Parker would pick the school owned by the church he was raised in. BYU was listed as one of his final choices. But he ultimately chose to spend his college years at Duke before attempting a career in the NBA. BYU fans were disappointed, but no one was truly surprised. Duke over BYU was the best choice for a young prospect in 2012. 

    A.J. Dybantsa.

    What changed between 2012 and 2024 when A.J. Dybantsa, the number one high school prospect, chose BYU over every other school? The answer is roughly $7 million dollars. That is what Dybantsa is reportedly making to play basketball at BYU. 

    The deal was supported by Utah Jazz owner Ryan Smith, who met multiple times with the Dybantsa family in multiple attempts to bring the young player to Provo. 

    According to Smith, he had no financial role in bringing Dybantsa to BYU, but the influence of Utah’s most famous billionaire acting as a “booster” or unofficial recruiter certainly swayed the decision.

    Prior to 2021, boosters acting as recruiters was taboo to the NCAA governing body. It was called improper recruiting. But in 2021, California began the modern era of NIL, or the ability of a college athlete to benefit from their name, image, or likeness, when they passed the “Fair Pay to Play Act.” 

    This new law gave college athletes in California the ability to benefit from their NIL, something that was banned in the rest of the country to that point. The NCAA saw that this law would create an unfair advantage for California schools that could now give young athletes the chance to make money off their talent and image while still in college. 

    The NCAA knew they needed to do something quickly, so they rushed through a policy that opened up NIL to all college athletes in the country, and it has been expanding and evolving over the last four years. 

    Grant Duff, who has coached at the University of Utah, Weber State University, and is now the defensive coordinator for Idaho State University, says, “The best part of NIL is that athletes have an opportunity to make good money. The downside comes with the free-for-all that money causes.”

    Dybantsa confers with BYU Head coach, Kevin Young.

    One of the biggest current examples of what a school can do when the boosters are willing to pay for success is Texas Tech University. From 2020-2024, Texas Tech had 34 wins, which works out to 6.8 wins per year with a low of 4 wins and high of 8. Then Texas Tech’s boosters got involved, led by Cody Campbell, an oil industry businessman and Chairman of the Texas Tech board. The football program was given 28 million dollars for NIL with a simple message attached to the large pile of money: Win. And win now. And win they did. 

    By signing NIL deals with athletes in the transfer portal, Texas Tech went from a middle-of-the-pack school in their conference to one of the top 12 teams in the country. They didn’t just win games in 2025, they made many of their opponents look like they didn’t belong on the same field, including the University of Utah and BYU twice. That is what money can buy.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • Cottonwood Heights Corruption Allegations: A Case That Never Reached a Courtroom

    A year ago, we here at Utah Stories recorded a podcast episode that we never published. We were revisiting corruption allegations from ten years ago. We decided not to publish the video, so it sat there on YouTube for nearly 12 months.

    Then somehow the video was published. How? We are not sure, but once it got out there, the comments came pouring in.

    Dozens of viewers, then hundreds, supported the video with their comments on our examination of allegations of police misconduct in Cottonwood Heights. The video recounts how the Police Department was reported by business owners as focusing enforcement on customers of the former Canyon Inn bar. These allegations did not result in a publicly documented, full investigation by Utah’s Justice Department nor the FBI (at least to our knowledge). So why rehash the past?

    We believe the story of The Canyon Inn (and other area business owners) vs. CHPD and Cottonwood Heights Mayor Kelvin Cullimore raises questions about what can happen when allegations surface and do not move forward through a formal legal process with state or federal oversight.

    In 2012, Cottonwood Heights business owners at the mouth of the canyons began publicly objecting to police activity whereby up to seven cruisers were pulling over 711 and Canyon Inn bar customers on their busiest evenings.

    According to those accounts, drivers leaving the bar were frequently pulled over by police and were given DUI tickets, sometimes even after passing a sobriety examination. The volume and concentration of those stops led residents and business owners to complain about the “heavy-handed treatment” of CHPD toward motorists, especially in and around the Canyon Inn and neighboring 711, and eventually the Porcupine Pub.

    Customers responded in predictable ways. Some chose not to return and avoid the area. Others went to different establishments. Over time, the owner of the Canyon Inn, Jim Stojack, stated that his revenue declined by 70% and that he believed police activity near his business was the main contributing factor.

    Utah Stories reported on these concerns by conducting interviews; gathering video documentation provided by those involved; and making public records requests. Through our GRAMA requests, we reviewed DUI citations issued by the Cottonwood Heights Police Department and examined how those cases were resolved in Holladay Justice Court. During that period, we observed a higher number based on our review of DUI cases dismissed in court due to lack of evidence compared to other jurisdictions. One DUI attorney, Tyler Ayers, went on record saying that CHPD was issuing a high volume of DUI citations that were later dismissed.

    That observation raised questions about how cases were being documented and prosecuted. It did not, on its own, establish intent or misconduct, but it became part of a broader set of concerns raised by multiple sources.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).