Community Relations

Preserving Theatrical History: Saving Pantages Theatre

In mid-March, the future of the Utah Pantages Theatre hung by a thread as supporters fought in court to stop developers from demolishing the once-glamorous century-old structure on Main Street.

|


 

SALT LAKE CITY In mid-March, the future of the Utah Pantages Theatre hung by a thread as supporters fought in court to stop developers from demolishing the once-glamorous century-old structure on Main Street.

On March 8, Third District Court Judge Robert Faust denied Friends of the Utah Pantages Cinematic Theatre’s request for a temporary restraining order that would block the wrecking ball’s blows while their case gets fully litigated. 

But with that denial, Faust granted Friends the chance to amend and strengthen their request. 

The nonprofit Friends which formed last June – includes case plaintiffs Michael Patton, Derek Bleazard, Casey McDonough and Ibrahima Fall, who filed their initial complaint in February against Salt Lake City Corporation and its Redevelopment Agency – a municipal board made up of Mayor Erin Mendenhall and city council members.

Patton, a self-described filmmaker and activist, said they planned to revise their request, add more defendants, and resubmit to the court as soon as possible.

“I found out about the theatre about 10 years ago when the city first bought it, and I was excited they were going to restore it,” Patton said. “But then in 2019, we found out about this new deal to destroy it.”

Since then, he’s been spearheading the effort to save and restore the Pantages theatre, which he considers both historically and culturally significant.

McDonough, an architect, worked to help establish the theatre’s eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places, an action that the State Historic Preservation Office had recommended the Redevelopment Agency pursue in 2019, according to court documents. 

On November 4, 2021, Salt Lake City’s Historic Landmark Commission unanimously approved making that recommendation of eligibility to the State Historic Preservation Office.

However, prior to the State Office’s scheduled meeting on November 18, the city conveyed the property’s title to Main Street Tower Owner, LLC a subsidiary of the Texas-based Hines Acquisition company. 

In a November 10 letter to the Utah Division of State History, Main Street Tower’s attorney Bruce Baird detailed his opposition to that historic designation.

“The unfortunate reality is that the property is beyond repair and there is not a financially viable use for restoration,” Baird said in his letter. 

But Patton disagrees, convinced that Pantages is a treasure that can be restored and once again bring in revenue.

“Pantages is not in a vacuum,” Patton said, noting its place among others designed by renowned architect B. Marcus Priteca. “There’s a Hollywood Pantages, one in Tacoma almost identical to ours, and also one in Toronto/Minneapolis.”

Patton also questioned the city’s projected restoration estimates. 

“The RDA has been inflating these numbers for years, saying it would cost $60 to $80 mil to restore,” Patton said.

According to Historic Theater News, restoration of Tacoma’s historic Pantages cost less than $25 million, which included seismic upgrades. That work finished in 2018. 

“It’s very doable,” Patton said of the Salt Lake City Pantages restoration, noting that landing a spot on the National Register would open the door for federal tax credits to help fund it. He also believes that grants, private donations from benefactors and other sources could be found to get the job done.

In December 2019, the Redevelopment Agency sold the property which was then valued at just over $4 million to Hines for $0. 

That agreement came with the stipulation that a mid-block walkway and family-friendly park with an entertainment venue would be included in the project. The developer also agreed to provide at least 10 percent of the housing units in the proposed mixed-use tower to households making 60 to 80 percent of area median income. 

The court document filed by Main Street Tower Owner LLC in opposition to the temporary restraining order described what they considered to be excessive behavior on the part of Patton and other plaintiffs.

“This is not Plaintiffs first, second or even third attempt to derail MSTO’s redevelopment efforts,” Baird said in the filing, noting their vigorous opposition at several City Council and RDA meetings, trespassing in the theater, along with a “smear social media campaign slandering Salt Lake City officials.”

Baird also wrote that a wrongful injunction blocking demolition could incur annual costs in the tens of millions of dollars due to delays in the property’s development.

“The injunction would adversely affect the public interest,” Baird concluded, urging denial of the temporary restraining order.

Depending on the court’s ultimate decision, demolition could begin shortly, rendering any further legal action to save Pantages moot.

RELATED CONTENT

Broken Promises — Historic Utah Theatre donated to a developer with an affordable housing promise. 

Cronyism and Corruption in Utah: Investigative Journalist Eric Peterson

Attack of the Developosaurus

Homeless Advocate Claims SLC Mayor Has a Conflict of Interest in Handling Homeless Situation

Former Utah Mayor Rocky Anderson—”I think the people should rise up!”

A brief history of newspapers in Utah

San Rafael Secrets: What Did Madame Marie Curie Do in the Middle of a Utah Desert?

Utah Volcanoes & Massacres: A Tour of Southern Utah’s Violent Past

Subscribe to Utah Stories weekly newsletter and get our stories directly to your inbox

* indicates required



 

, , , , ,


Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.


  • Ogden Utah: Boomtown, Bargain, or Utah’s Next Unaffordable City?

    With its reinvigorated downtown and close proximity to mountains and river pathways, this northern Utah city is enjoying a renaissance. Ogden’s stock of affordable housing — compared to other metros along the Wasatch Front — currently draws people in for a closer look. 


  • The Utah Bombings That Exposed One of America’s Greatest Forgers

    On an ordinary October morning in 1985, downtown Salt Lake City was shattered by a blast that killed businessman and document collector Steve Christensen. Hours later, a second bomb tore through a quiet Holladay neighborhood, killing Kathy Sheets, the wife of Christensen’s former business partner. The next day saw a third explosion. This one was in a car near Temple Square that nearly killed rare-documents dealer Mark Hofmann. 

    Rumors swirled instantly, tying the attacks to money, religion, and shadowy early-Mormon documents Christensen had recently acquired. For days, Utah held its breath. What unfolded was stranger and darker than fiction. The bombs weren’t the work of religious extremists or enemies of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but instead, the doings of Mark Hofmann himself. Hofmann was a nerdy, soft-spoken dealer who had secretly become one of the most skilled document forgers in American history. 

    His creations were so convincing that they reshaped historical narratives, fooling scholars, collectors, and church leaders. When the lies began to close in, the bombs became his final, desperate attempt to keep his world from collapsing.

    Hofmann had been fabricating Mormon and American historical documents for years. He was a prodigy of deception, sourcing period paper, mixing inks that cracked just right, and mimicking handwriting with obsessive precision. Most of all, he knew how to read people. Utah in the 1970s and ’80s was a collector’s paradise. As bookseller Ken Sanders told Salt Lake Magazine, it was “a consciousness shift,” a recognition that rare Utah history was a treasure worth pursuing. It was also, he notes, fertile ground for affinity fraud.

    Nothing captured that vulnerability more than the Salamander Letter, a supposed 1830s correspondence which claimed Joseph Smith encountered a magical white salamander rather than an angel. The document shook Latter-day Saint circles. Church leaders, worried about its implications, quietly purchased it along with other materials Hofmann dangled before them. Many reasoned that if the church was willing to buy it, then it must be authentic and true, and Hofmann understood that psychology perfectly.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • The End of an Era? FanX and the Salt Palace Closure

    For more than a decade, FanX has called the Salt Palace home. With the convention center set to close for a massive renovation, founder Dan Farr is preparing for a new chapter while planning one final celebration in its longtime venue.


  • The Stratos Project and Corporate Power: Who Controls Utah’s Future?

    If we were all just consumers, Governor Cox, Mike Lee, Speaker Schultz, and Kevin O’Leary would have it easy. If we were just more concerned about money, jobs, and tech, and less concerned about raising our kids in communities (not in front of screens), culture, the environment, and water, those smart dudes would get exactly what they want — Stratos: a city of the future, buzzing with processors and transistors, making all of our AI dreams come true! 

    The world we could live in would be a dazzling, Mr. Wonderful kind of place. We would beat those pesky Chinese in the AI war; our AI robots could do all of our farming and ostensibly harvest the water we need for the Great Salt Lake out of thin air. But apparently, we just don’t get it. We haven’t yet reached the point predicted by Aldous Huxley’s vision in Brave New World, where we are completely distracted, dopamine-driven consumers who only need sex, drugs, and stuff to remain happy.

    Maybe Stratos will be an amazing marvel, and somehow, as Governor Cox claims, “. . . add more water to the Great Salt Lake.” But we aren’t sold. While this Stratos project has received considerable attention, it’s worth taking a step back to attempt to understand how corporate power appears to have usurped civic power.

    Civics is the practice of shaping our society through our collective voices and community involvement. Ask the residents in Tremonton, Utah how well that is working out for them. Can we still shape our world through our elected leaders? Does it matter who we vote for at the ballot box if organizations like UDOT, UTA, and MIDA can supersede our local government authority and citizen backlash? 

    The corporatization of our communities and the interests that impact our political leaders’ decision making processes are seen as far more of a concern than the average Utah resident’s concerns. Special interests and corporate power are shaping Utah’s future more than ever. 

    It’s worth asking: ‘How can we regain control over shaping Utah’s future in light of the growing power and billions that the technocrats now wield in shaping our world today?’ Amazon’s market cap exceeds the GDP of Canada. The “Magnificent Seven” tech stocks now have a greater market cap than the entire GDP of Europe ($23.6 trillion. EU countries have $19.3 trillion GDP). Will tech companies become their own nation-states and dominate their own chunks of various states? Will we become their subjects?

    There are two sides to this coin: We love Utah not just because we have the most outdoor wilderness playgrounds, but also because of Utah’s prosperity and job market. This is because Utah has become a tech hub. Our tech leadership has minted several billionaires and billion-dollar businesses. Utah offers a market and an educated workforce that more businesses and giant corporations want to be a part of. This is a benefit for even non-tech Utahns.

    The problem with this success is that as we dole out more money to attract more tech businesses, data centers, fulfillment centers, and big corporate retailers, it becomes more difficult to carve out our “sense of community.” As corporate sovereignty replaces local business sovereignty, we see that our voices and our votes matter less.

    Ask who our politicians work for, and nearly every Utahn believes they work far more for their corporate donors than they work for the average Utah citizen. So how do we best regain control over our communities?

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).