Shattering the Pictures in Our Heads: Challenging the Myth about Native Americans

Karem Orrego’s exhibit presents a 360-degree video “cube” of personal narratives of the Shoshone-Paiute tribe of Duck Valley Reservation.

Guy Wheatley

March 20, 2022

We’ve sluggishly pushed through the dreaded Omicron surge this winter, but the light has emerged at the end of the tunnel for art-lovers. On Friday February 18th the UMOCA downtown re-opened its doors to great fanfare with five brand new exhibits. The jet-set was out with the student body and general public alike into a raucous and lively set courtesy of DJ Shaadie. Exhibits ranged from the soulful and poignant, like Lilly Agar’s A Hug Away and Myleka Bevens We’re going to Talk About It, to the downright whimsical—there was a meditative disco chamber on the bottom floor for your inner superfly Tibetan monk.

Connection to our heritage is a big deal—we can use sites like Ancestry.com and 23andme.com to trace our bloodline to an Irish farmer fleeing the great famine of 1848 or a dutch merchant plying his trade in old New Amsterdam. But it can be easy to overlook the narratives of the original inhabitants of America, pre-colonization. Many names are used, but the term “First Peoples” is most to the point.

This brings me to one of the aforementioned five exhibits: Shattering the Pictures in Our Heads. The creator and artist, Karem Orrego (previously a festival coordinator who worked for Utah Stories), spoke with me here on opening night about her process and own aims in the exhibition.

“I was inspired by Carol Dalrymple, founder of the Edge of Discovery project who was already working with the Shoshone-Paiute tribes. I was focused on the idea of a difficult past, how to survive it. It wasn’t only about making short films, but empowering youth and exploring Native American representation with technology.”

Karem’s exhibit which presents a 360-degree video “cube” of personal narratives of the Shoshone-Paiute tribe of Duck Valley Reservation in Idaho, intercut with archival footage of popular stock types of the so-called “Indian” in much of our popular 20th century media—the noble savage, the bloodthirsty warrior, the sage medicine man, the doe-like ingénue. It challenges the viewer presenting many of the caricatures that have been hammered into our collective consciousness through decades of popular TV & film westerns.

“In Latin America, we also had a history of being colonized. Different peoples, but same story. We expanded the project from one short film into a larger conversation with other native Americans about the trauma of what it’s like to live in a place that tries to isolate them. Some were survivors of boarding schools.”

As a native Peruvian Karem is a person of color herself and initially a foreigner to Utah, so she knows something about “shattering” preconceptions. Her initial impression of America’s Indigenous peoples was in fact based on old cowboys and Indian films that her grandfather was a fan of.

“When I first attended the reservation people were in awe of what I was doing and very curious. I was still in college and had some trepidation myself about what to expect. But the residents just want others to listen to their story, same as anyone, and we’re hoping to share that.”

One part of the video has a photographer framing the subjects in a shot. You overhear: “Do they need to look more stoic?” The idea of the authentic “stoic” Indian is an archetype that can be traced back to Edward Curtis, a photographer from the late 19th and early 20th centuries who always posed his native subjects as grim and unsmiling. A myth perpetuated even by other indigenous peoples as seen in a conversation between Victor and Thomas about being a “real Indian” in the late 90s cult film Smoke Signals. But as we watch Orrego’s subjects break into laughter and an easy smile the stoic “real Indian” is just that—a myth.

“We may be from different places but there is still a connection on the subject of being misunderstood or misrepresented. I made sure to listen to my students’ stories and be genuine. They had moments of laughter, happiness, and curiosity. I was there to support and get inspired by them.”

Karem attended the U of U before eventually graduating in 2016 with a bachelor degree in Film and Media Studies. She recommends everyone see Reservation Docs (a new FX TV series that first aired in 2021 using all indigenous writers and directors) and to stay tuned for more projects in the parent program Edge of Discovery.

Shattering the Pictures in Our Heads runs at UMOCA through April 30th, 2022.

Subscribe to Utah Stories weekly newsletter and get our stories directly to your inbox

Community Relations, Local Spotlight, Utah Artists, Utah Stories

art

Guy Wheatley

Community Relations

Ogden Valley City Incorporates as Voters Deliver a Surprising Mayoral Outcome

Ogden Valley City has officially incorporated at a pivotal moment for northern Utah, just as growth pressures tied to the 2034 Winter Olympics begin to accelerate. Voters also delivered an unexpected mayoral outcome, setting the tone for how the new city will approach land use, local control, and the work of building a government from the ground up.

To access this post, you must purchase Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).
Utah Stories

Utah Winter Events Calendar: Ice Skating, Festivals, and Things to Do in January–February 2026

From ice skating at Millcreek Common, Gallivan Center, and the Utah Olympic Oval to winter festivals, outdoor adventures, and cultural events across the state, this January–February calendar highlights a wide range of activities happening throughout Utah, from Bluff Balloon Festival and SkiJoring Utah to concerts, races, and seasonal celebrations.
Community Relations

Has Utah’s Soft-on-Crime Justice Reform Made Communities Safer?

Has this “soft-on-crime” approach resulted in safer streets?

SALT LAKE CITY — A decade has passed since former Utah Governor Gary Herbert signed a massive justice reform bill into law in hopes that the state could reduce its prison population and manage low-level offenders through rehabilitation programs instead of incarceration. Has this reinvestment resulted in lower crime and recidivism rates?

According to the Utah Department of Corrections, that landmark Justice Reinvestment Initiative aimed to “continue holding offenders accountable and securing our communities, but in a way that considers individual risks and treatment needs.”

Are communities really safer when mental health and substance use needs are addressed through programs administered outside prison walls? The idea was to treat criminals differently based on their mental health needs and backgrounds. But at least one retired Adult Probation and Parole Officer, believes this “soft-on-crime” approach hasn’t resulted in safer streets.

LOOKING BACK

State Senator Todd Weiler, in that legislative role since 2012, helped drive the passage of the Justice Reinvestment Initiative (JRI), a massive bill that enjoyed broad-based approval among state officials and the Legislature as a whole.

In November 2014, Weiler attended the national summit on the issue in San Diego, an event hosted by Pew Charitable Trusts.

“I was very involved in it. We had a lot of high hopes,” Weiler, a Woods Cross Republican, said in a recent interview. “That was about the time we were finalizing plans for the new prison. And we actually said that because of JRI we don’t need as many beds because we’ll be incarcerating fewer people. So that new prison was designed with this idea.”

A key part of JRI dealt with adjusting sentencing for crimes related to addiction, dividing offenders into two basic groups: dangerous criminals who are a threat to society (that group goes to prison), and low-level offenders who get help kicking addictions through state-sponsored programs or private-sector rehabilitation.

“The ultimate goal was if we have an otherwise good person who got caught up in an addiction, and as a result committed crimes, they need to be punished for their crimes,” Weiler said. “It’s not that we’re going to overlook what they did, but we wanted to focus primarily on helping them overcome their addiction and [that means] getting them back to their job and their family.”

Before JRI, low-level drug offenders with felonies would spend years in prison, which wreaked havoc with their lives and future prospects. Addressing the root cause of their theft and property crimes through supervision and treatment made sense.

“We’re all imperfect people,” Weiler said. “So we want people working their jobs, paying their bills and raising their kids rather than sitting in jail and watching TV or playing cards.”

To access this post, you must purchase Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).
Community Relations

Salt Lake City Newcomers Club: Finding Friendship and Belonging Since 1948

Moving away from your hometown can come with many blessings. But for some, it also comes with just as many bouts of loneliness. That ache of not knowing where to meet people, or grieving the friends you left behind, comes in waves. Workplaces and churches can sometimes provide ready-made communities, but what happens when they don’t? Where do you go to find true belonging?