Could Tiny Homes Be the Answer to Utah’s Affordable Housing Shortage?

A Tiny Home Village is A Much Better Solution Than “Housing First” to Alleviate Utah’s Affordable Housing Crisis

May 4, 2021

A Tiny Home Village is A Much Better Solution Than “Housing First” to Alleviate Utah’s Affordable Housing Crisis

A tiny home village in Austin, Texas called Community First! Village, has been working to help alleviate the working-poor homeless gap in Austin, Texas, which is even more of a boom-town than Salt Lake City.

It’s a much better solution for the working poor because it requires everyone to pay rent and remain clean. Unlike Salt Lake City’s lauded homeless program, Housing First, which was designed to “give free homes to the homeless.” It helps the working poor maintain jobs, if not in the workforce but within the community of Mobile Loaves and Fishes, or on-site maintaining the grounds as a requirement to maintain occupancy in the village.

Housing First has allowed a subsistence class of Salt Lake City residents to live with free rent and housing. It has never been demonstrated that by providing the material necessities to maintain life alleviates despair or the feeling that a person is worthless.

Free housing where applicants need to prove desperation, or chronic chemical dependence, or alcoholism, or mental illness to qualify doesn’t reward good behavior, but ensures dependency on tax-payer handouts and essentially rewards bad behavior. Free housing doesn’t offer residents the confidence that their life has value or purpose. Salt Lake City needs a solution that builds community, value, and purpose into the equation.

Austin, Texas has proven that tiny home villages are a much better solution. Just from a simple mathematical and economic perspective, it makes sense. 500-1,000 square foot homes ranging in rents from $300-$900; and ranging in amenities from having full tiny kitchens and baths, to community kitchens and baths. Tiny homes are far more affordable to build, and they provide first-time homebuyers a truly affordable option, along with a true community of people who are working to maintain their own living.

With the latest news that Salt Lake County’s new average home is nearly $500,000, this sounds like the very best option to alleviate the homelessness and affordable housing crisis.

Austin’s Tiny home projects underway

Austin’s Community First! Village

Subscribe to Utah Stories weekly newsletter and get our stories directly to your inbox

Utah Stories

affordable housing Salt Lake, homeless, tiny homes village

Richard Markosian

I am a story teller and journalist. I have a passion for farmers, local craftspeople, and folks who aspire to create, build and grow their business in the local marketplace. Why local? By supporting locally-owned businesses we create more opportunity for entrepreneurs, and we claim our sovereignty to shape our communities how we want to see them. I aspire to build Utah Stories Magazine into a household Utah name, and assist Utah businesses and makers with marketing. On the journalism side of things my passion is investigative journalism that offers true insight into issues. I believe strongly in the forth estate: strong, meaningful, insightful journalism is essential to a free market Democracy.

Utah Stories

The Utah Farm That Refuses to Give Up as Development Closes In

Running a farm is hard enough, but rapid city growth makes it even tougher. More than a decade ago, the late Verl Cook faced a series of staggering hurdles that threatened to wipe out his family’s livelihood.

First, the city decided to treat the Cook’s greenhouse — the most profitable part of the farm — like a big-box retail store. They demanded the family build a paved parking lot, a project that would cost $200,000.
Farms

Future Craft Farm Launches First CSA Season in Salt Lake City

Hall and Scheig found their land last June and broke ground just two months later, transforming what was essentially a blank canvas into a diversified market garden. This year marks their first full growing season, and they’re launching it with a community supported agriculture program, or CSA. CSAs allow people to support local growers by purchasing a season’s worth of produce upfront, giving farmers the financial stability they need during the most expensive part of the year.
Utah Stories

Why Utah Loves Dirty Soda: The Story Behind the State’s Sweetest Craze

Why would a state known for avoiding coffee create one of America’s most successful beverage trends? Why would people willingly add cream and flavored syrups to drinks that already contain more than enough sugar? And why are Utahns willing to wait in long drive-thru lines for something they could technically make at home?
Utah Stories

Utah’s Housing Debate Misses the Question That Matters Most

A generation ago, homeownership was not reserved for the affluent. Working-class families bought modest homes on modest incomes. They built equity, raised families, and entered retirement with a valuable asset largely paid for.

Today, many Utah families find themselves in a different position. They may earn too much to qualify for housing assistance but too little to purchase a home. They rent apartments that consume an increasing share of their income while saving for a down payment becomes increasingly difficult.