Utah Stories

Who Does Utah Love? Big Business Gets Big Breaks

Utah offers tax incentives to lure big business to the state, but what about local businesses?

|


DSC_0249Utah government is all about the business of business–keeping red tape to a minimum so that companies can keep making green. It’s also why the Utah Governor’s Office actively lures major out-of-state companies to expand into the state. The Governor’s Office of Economic Development, or GOED, offers tax credits to companies that relocate or expand here, but only after the company starts generating real local jobs. Since 2008, GOED has doled out hundreds of millions of incentives to companies, estimating that over the next two decades these companies will have brought 40,000 new jobs to the state. So far, 14,000 of those jobs have already been created according to GOED spokesman Michael Sullivan.

But the carrots dangled by GOED aren’t for just any old job creator. Critics point out the incentives aren’t offered to small, local mom-and-pop entrepreneurs that may instead be displaced from the market by the presence of these out-of-state behemoth businesses.

Sullivan, however, says that GOED’s incentives are fair to the communities that are asked to welcome new or expanded businesses. For one thing, incentives are not offered to retail operations, and incentives go only to companies that can bring in at least 50 new jobs. Also, a local community must approve the relocation or expansion of a business.

“The state never pushes a company down the throat of a community that doesn’t want it,” Sullivan says. He also points out that GOED doesn’t exclude all local businesses, noting that since 2008, 63 percent of tax credits have gone to businesses that had existing operations in the state.

He also points out that the Governor’s office works hard to help out small operations, not with tax breaks, but with a partnership with the federal government to fund 14 Small Business Development Centers spread across the state–largely in rural counties. These centers offer marketing and financing advice to small companies. The governor’s office also helps these small companies bid on local, state and federal contracts. In fiscal year 2015 alone, these companies, many of them with fewer than 50 employees, were able to nab $390 million in government contract work.

For critics such as Connor Boyack of the libertarian minded Libertas Institute, however, it’s impossible to ignore the advantage tax breaks lend to a big corporation as opposed to small companies.

“Providing tax breaks to recruit out-of-state businesses is a slap in the face to local companies, and imposes on them and their employees a disproportionate tax burden and competitive disadvantage,” Boyack says. “Utah is constitutionally required to have a free market, but it seems the governor’s office hasn’t gotten the memo.”

For Sullivan, however, it comes down to simple math.

“What’s the more logical [approach]?” Sullivan asks. “Give a thousand incentives to companies to add one job each, or give one incentive to a company to add 1,000 jobs?”

Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.


  • Artist Kate Kilpatrick Brings Utah’s History to Life Through Murals

    “I think we’re all interconnected; as individuals as well as societies,” Kilpatrick notes. Her work showcases those connections exuberantly, and whatever scale she’s working on, you can bet that in terms of energy and spirit, she’s painting large.


  • Why Most People Stay Stuck in Business and What It Takes to Move Forward

    Every so often, you meet an immigrant who came here with almost nothing and managed to build something exceptional.

    Prakash Shah is the kind of man who has spent enough time around risk that he no longer treats it like an interruption.

    Today, he works in business brokerage and advisory, helping owners sell companies, helping buyers decide whether they should step in, and, when the fit is right, helping connect those buyers with private equity. He works in a world of valuations, leverage, due diligence, and hard questions that most people would rather postpone. He also operates in Utah real estate and has built a career around seeing value before it is obvious to everyone else. That is who he is now. What makes him interesting is how early that instinct started to form, and how little his life resembles the way most Americans are raised to think about comfort, career, and security.

    He grew up in Nepal in a boarding school system that would feel severe to many Americans. He was an only child, yet he saw his parents only twice a year for twelve straight years, until high school graduation. He lived inside routine. He shared space with boys from different social classes and different family circumstances. The school was structured enough that money did not buy you any special standing once you were inside. Everyone followed the same rules. Everyone was subject to the same discipline. In his case, it was an army school. Everything was measured. Everything was scheduled. In that kind of environment, you do not build your life around preference. You build it around adaptation.

    That contrast matters.

    A lot of American children are raised to search for what fits them. What are you passionate about? What do you enjoy? What feels right? Those are not bad questions, but they can create a habit of waiting for life to align itself before action begins. Prakash learned something else much earlier. He learned that life often does not align itself first. You enter the room as it is, you deal with the people in it, and you figure out how to function without making your comfort the center of every decision. He said that one of the biggest lessons from those years was tolerance, the ability to live with people from all walks of life and genuinely learn to get along with them. That is not a soft value. In business, it turns into resilience. In negotiation, it turns into patience. In career terms, it turns into range.

    When he came to the United States over 25 years ago, he did not arrive with the kind of runway that allows for a prolonged identity search. He came with two suitcases and enough money for one semester. He went to Hunter College in New York City, then to NYIT near Central Park, studying media and then media and technology management. He also studied psychology. Those details matter because they show something about his mind. He was interested in people before he built a career around deals. Even then, what attracted him was not technical prestige. It was understanding motives, behavior, and how people reveal themselves.

    But New York is merciless toward vague ambition. It demands payment in rent, transit, food, and time.

    Prakash worked constantly. He took multiple jobs. He paid tuition, paid rent, and skipped most of what Americans imagine as college life. There were no romantic years of drifting from café to concert to self-discovery. He talked about not having the luxury of dates, travel, or finding himself. He was working. Even laundry was not a small detail. In New York, he pointed out, you do not just throw clothes in a machine at home. You haul them to the laundromat, count quarters, and measure what is necessary. He also described distraction in a way that most native-born Americans probably do not think about. For immigrants, distraction is not always pleasure. Sometimes distraction is the constant pressure of competing needs. Tuition or rent. Food or savings. A better coat or another month of making do. He was not romanticizing the struggle. He was describing the arithmetic of it.

    That arithmetic did not make him cautious. If anything, it did the opposite.

    While in college, he had the option of safer analytical work. Instead, he took a sales job with Time Warner Cable that sent him into the South Bronx from 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. to knock on doors. He is not a physically imposing man. He knew exactly what kind of neighborhoods he was walking into. He described apartment buildings where people kept pit bulls, where tension was normal, where one mistake in tone or timing could end a conversation immediately. For most people, that kind of job would have been something to survive and forget. For him, it became a school in human behavior. “It’s not about talking… it’s about listening,” he said.

    One story from that period says almost everything about how he operates. He knocked on a door one night around 8:45 and found himself facing a huge man with a gun on the table, pit bulls nearby, and a half-eaten pizza in front of him. It had all the ingredients of a very bad scene.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • Ancient Pyramid Discovered in Sugar House Park, Salt Lake City

    A Salt Lake City resident says he may have uncovered what he believes to be a buried structure beneath a well-known hill in Sugar House Park, raising questions that have drawn both curiosity and skepticism.


  • Utah Fits All Scholarship Applications Open Through April 30 for K–12 Students

    Utah families have more learning paths than ever and, increasingly, more ways to make those paths affordable. This spring, the Utah Fits All Scholarship opened  for new family applications on April 1, and the application window stays open for one month. The program is a public K–12 scholarship that provides $4,000 to $8,000 per student,…