Investigation

The Ups and Downs of Mormon Media

Amidst fierce competition, the Deseret News has a brave new plan to save their paper. But at what cost?

|


by Jacob Hodgen

Amidst fierce competition, the Deseret News has a brave new plan to save their paper. But at what cost?.

It has been one heck of a year for Utah’s longest-running newspaper.

The Deseret News just announced it would soon be jettisoning 43% of its staff, including its entire design department. Spinning the move as a bold step and part of a plan to “lead and innovate” and to “become a leader in the industry and a model for change,” the Deseret News certainly isn’t the only paper to have experienced relevancy issues in a culture rapidly shifting away from conventional models of print journalism.

news oress

However, breaking up is hard to do, and the DN’s attempt to transition to the brave new world of New Media has been a messy one.

Within one day of announcing their layoffs, the DN set off yet another firestorm when it revealed that it was now enlisting the help of Michael Purdy as a special correspondent. The SL Tribune was quick to point out that Purdy, in addition to his brand new reporter duties with the DN, just so happens to also be an official public relations agent for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

It is no secret that the Desert Media group, which consists of the Deseret News, KSL, and Deseret Book, is owned by the LDS Church. However, deputizing the church’s own ad men and calling them reporters is a bold move indeed and seems to reflect the paper’s trend towards media hyper specialization.

In the same way that Fox News and MSNBC have managed to thrive in the cable news business by dropping any pretense of neutrality and catering to a particular audience, part of the DN’s plan to “lead and innovate” seems to be to focus even more on its Mormon fan base.

Part of the transition involved the stepping down of short-lived Editor Joe Cannon, who had only held the position for three years. Under Cannon’s leadership, the DN became “one of the fastest-growing newspapers in the country,” but it turns out that this was mostly due to web traffic, which explains the decision to go for broke with the online version of their paper.

The DN isn’t the only long-running newspaper to turn its focus away from print publication. In May of last year, The Christian Science Monitor published its final hard copy and then went exclusively to electronic publication. By focusing on paperless publication, The CSM reports it hopes to quintuple its online readership in five years.

Even if they don’t fully meet their goals, it’s numbers like these that put butterflies in the stomachs of overhead-wary newspaper publishers.

The DN explains it plans to create an online group of “hundreds of contributors and thought leaders” from across the country with something called “Deseret Connect.” The project will enlist citizen journalists who will be controlled by an editorial advisory board from the paper. Considering the heat they already took this summer after their previous advisory board admitted to covering up a sex scandal for House Majority leader and eminent Mormon Kevin Garn for years, a focus on a religiously loyal audience that doesn’t care about those type of things is probably a pretty good idea.

In 2009, Mark Willes, the former DN publisher and nephew of the late Gordon B. Hinckley, claimed that he was “wary of the trustworthiness of the internet” and said he believed newspapers were the “bulwark of liberty.”

For 2010 and beyond, the new Deseret News staff had better hope that he was wrong. §

, , ,

Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.


  • The Utah Bombings That Exposed One of America’s Greatest Forgers

    On an ordinary October morning in 1985, downtown Salt Lake City was shattered by a blast that killed businessman and document collector Steve Christensen. Hours later, a second bomb tore through a quiet Holladay neighborhood, killing Kathy Sheets, the wife of Christensen’s former business partner. The next day saw a third explosion. This one was in a car near Temple Square that nearly killed rare-documents dealer Mark Hofmann. 

    Rumors swirled instantly, tying the attacks to money, religion, and shadowy early-Mormon documents Christensen had recently acquired. For days, Utah held its breath. What unfolded was stranger and darker than fiction. The bombs weren’t the work of religious extremists or enemies of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but instead, the doings of Mark Hofmann himself. Hofmann was a nerdy, soft-spoken dealer who had secretly become one of the most skilled document forgers in American history. 

    His creations were so convincing that they reshaped historical narratives, fooling scholars, collectors, and church leaders. When the lies began to close in, the bombs became his final, desperate attempt to keep his world from collapsing.

    Hofmann had been fabricating Mormon and American historical documents for years. He was a prodigy of deception, sourcing period paper, mixing inks that cracked just right, and mimicking handwriting with obsessive precision. Most of all, he knew how to read people. Utah in the 1970s and ’80s was a collector’s paradise. As bookseller Ken Sanders told Salt Lake Magazine, it was “a consciousness shift,” a recognition that rare Utah history was a treasure worth pursuing. It was also, he notes, fertile ground for affinity fraud.

    Nothing captured that vulnerability more than the Salamander Letter, a supposed 1830s correspondence which claimed Joseph Smith encountered a magical white salamander rather than an angel. The document shook Latter-day Saint circles. Church leaders, worried about its implications, quietly purchased it along with other materials Hofmann dangled before them. Many reasoned that if the church was willing to buy it, then it must be authentic and true, and Hofmann understood that psychology perfectly.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • What Was Happening Inside Phillips Plaza Before the Murder in Salt Lake?

    Three days before Ralph Hoffman was killed, Utah Stories interviewed Phillips Plaza residents who described security concerns, unauthorized visitors, and questions about how vulnerable tenants were being supervised. After the murder, many of those concerns remain unanswered.


  • The Stratos Project and Corporate Power: Who Controls Utah’s Future?

    If we were all just consumers, Governor Cox, Mike Lee, Speaker Schultz, and Kevin O’Leary would have it easy. If we were just more concerned about money, jobs, and tech, and less concerned about raising our kids in communities (not in front of screens), culture, the environment, and water, those smart dudes would get exactly what they want — Stratos: a city of the future, buzzing with processors and transistors, making all of our AI dreams come true! 

    The world we could live in would be a dazzling, Mr. Wonderful kind of place. We would beat those pesky Chinese in the AI war; our AI robots could do all of our farming and ostensibly harvest the water we need for the Great Salt Lake out of thin air. But apparently, we just don’t get it. We haven’t yet reached the point predicted by Aldous Huxley’s vision in Brave New World, where we are completely distracted, dopamine-driven consumers who only need sex, drugs, and stuff to remain happy.

    Maybe Stratos will be an amazing marvel, and somehow, as Governor Cox claims, “. . . add more water to the Great Salt Lake.” But we aren’t sold. While this Stratos project has received considerable attention, it’s worth taking a step back to attempt to understand how corporate power appears to have usurped civic power.

    Civics is the practice of shaping our society through our collective voices and community involvement. Ask the residents in Tremonton, Utah how well that is working out for them. Can we still shape our world through our elected leaders? Does it matter who we vote for at the ballot box if organizations like UDOT, UTA, and MIDA can supersede our local government authority and citizen backlash? 

    The corporatization of our communities and the interests that impact our political leaders’ decision making processes are seen as far more of a concern than the average Utah resident’s concerns. Special interests and corporate power are shaping Utah’s future more than ever. 

    It’s worth asking: ‘How can we regain control over shaping Utah’s future in light of the growing power and billions that the technocrats now wield in shaping our world today?’ Amazon’s market cap exceeds the GDP of Canada. The “Magnificent Seven” tech stocks now have a greater market cap than the entire GDP of Europe ($23.6 trillion. EU countries have $19.3 trillion GDP). Will tech companies become their own nation-states and dominate their own chunks of various states? Will we become their subjects?

    There are two sides to this coin: We love Utah not just because we have the most outdoor wilderness playgrounds, but also because of Utah’s prosperity and job market. This is because Utah has become a tech hub. Our tech leadership has minted several billionaires and billion-dollar businesses. Utah offers a market and an educated workforce that more businesses and giant corporations want to be a part of. This is a benefit for even non-tech Utahns.

    The problem with this success is that as we dole out more money to attract more tech businesses, data centers, fulfillment centers, and big corporate retailers, it becomes more difficult to carve out our “sense of community.” As corporate sovereignty replaces local business sovereignty, we see that our voices and our votes matter less.

    Ask who our politicians work for, and nearly every Utahn believes they work far more for their corporate donors than they work for the average Utah citizen. So how do we best regain control over our communities?

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • The Art Floral: 75 Years as Salt Lake City’s Family-Owned Florist

    At 580 East 300 South in Salt Lake City, The Art Floral stands as one of downtown’s most enduring family businesses. In an era of overnight startups and short-lived storefronts, three-quarters of a century feels almost radical. Once inside, the air shifts, greenery mingles with fresh flowers, while tissue paper rustles, and shears snip rhythmically.