Why Utah's Developers/Politicians Do Not Want Tiny Homes

Why Utah’s Developers/Politicians Do Not Want Tiny Homes

When examining the problem of affordable housing one finds that there are two major components to it: zoning restrictions and the need for additional bicycle path infrastructure.

Richard Markosian

June 13, 2022

When examining the problem of affordable housing one finds that there are two major components to it: zoning restrictions and the need for additional bicycle path infrastructure.

Problem #1: Zoning Restrictions

Current zoning restrictions prohibit and prevent affordable housing. While this is true, this is in essence saying the part our government leaders don’t want to say it out loud, so it must be whispered.

Government leaders pretend that the lack of affordable housing is due to greedy developers who just refuse to build affordable housing. This isn’t true. A lot of developers would step up and build affordable housing if it made financial sense, but it doesn’t because zoning restrictions prohibit the building of affordable housing or housing below around $200 per square foot. Most housing now around SLC is upwards of $350 per square foot. Why is it so expensive? For many reasons but mainly because everyone must build homes in a very specific manner: according to codes and zoning requirements and to do this we must hire a General Contractor who knows the codes, who then hires subcontractors who build to code. This requirement for everyone who wants a roof over their heads to follow codes and zoning is what makes housing unaffordable. So why not change codes and zoning?

Especially here in Utah, political leaders and developers are often one and the same or working for each other. This is why there is currently a moratorium on building any more homeless shelter spaces in Salt Lake City. Homeless shelters can drive down property values. There is a major need for more shelter space or at least a city-sanctioned homeless campground, but it is not going to happen any time soon. Why? Because our political leaders are more concerned about protecting high-end developments and downtown properties than the possible concern they might have over the homeless freezing in the cold. (as we have been covering at Utah Stories since last winter).

For this reason, we are not seeing any tiny home communities, modular homes exemptions, or quarter-acre lots being broken into tiny-home lots. The only action being taken towards infill development in solving our housing shortage is to allow for more ADUs (accessory dwelling units) and more expensive condos getting permitted to rise a few stories higher than they were a decade ago.

If zoning restrictions were eased to allow for tiny home communities, this could make an enormous difference in increasing the affordable housing supply near the city. This is because the cost per square foot could be less than $150 or even less if modular homes or even high-end tents or yurts were permitted. But currently, here in Utah, we are making little progress, with the exception of the Other Side Village, which has been delayed over and over again because they aren’t getting the PR support they need from political leaders.

To be fair it isn’t just political leaders who are scared and who protest zoning changes, but also, NIMBYISM (Not In My Backyard!) residents are also preventing this problem from being solved. However, this could be solved with more public-awareness campaigns and spending on showing how other cities such as Austin, Texas’ tiny home communities are solving their affordable housing problems by easing restrictions on zoning and allowing affordable housing models to be constructed in suburban areas.

How Tiny Home Communities Work

Imagining a tiny home a person may assume that we are talking about living in a shed or former chicken coop in someone’s back yard. This is not the case.

A tiny home is a much more affordable housing option because building costs are lowered by reducing overall square footage. Tiny homes still require all electrical, gas, and water hook-ups just like a normal home. Also, just like regular homes, construction needs to be built to specific safety codes.

The main difference is that tiny home codes are not the same codes as traditional housing. The codes for tiny homes don’t exist in most cities and states so tiny home builders adhere to the codes for trailer homes or custom RVs. Heating, electrical, and plumbing requirements are all scaled down, and often the home itself must remain modular and portable because cities don’t wish to change their codes to accommodate tiny homes or true “deeply affordable housing”.

But how tiny homes can save a huge amount of money for first-time home buyers is by using far less land than traditional housing. A tiny home can sit on as little as a 15’ x 30’ footprint, add on a front porch and small garden area and the entire lot size for a tiny home could be as small as 30’ x 40’ or just 1,200 sqft; compare this to a traditional lot size which is 1/5th of an acre or 8,567 sqft. This means 5-7 tiny homes could be offered on a traditional home lot. And homeowners could more easily build their own tiny homes than traditional homes.

Why Tiny Homes Make Sense For First-Time Home Buyers

Tiny homes are usually two stories, with the second story being a loft sleeping area, and the bottom level providing the living space: kitchen, bath, and possible convertible second sleeping area.

But the lot size and the potential to put as many as seven tiny homes on a traditional lot (if zoning permitted) would allow for a lot’s purchase price of around $80K and a building cost ranging from $80K to even as little as $12K (if the home-owner would like to build the home themself). Contrast this with current single-family housing price home prices in Salt Lake City’s urban areas fetching $400K. Tiny homes have the major advantage of cutting way down on construction costs because they can be built in a modular manner in factories, and even 3D printed. But some still balk at the idea of a 550-square-foot home for over $100,000.

Compare this price with the cost of renting a comparable-sized studio apartment, in which owners don’t build equity, which also may have HOA fees, additional parking fees, utilities etc. and the concept begins to make a lot of sense. First-time homeownership among those in their twenties shouldn’t be only open to doctors, lawyers, and engineers.

Building equity in real estate at a young age is a key component to wealth building and enjoying a greater degree of independence and a much more secure retirement. But tiny homes alone can’t solve our affordable housing crisis in Utah. There is another aspect to the problem that is eating away at residents’ savings, preventing wealth building, and dirtying our air. The second problem is energy and transportation which we will get into in the next part.

Tiny Houses May be the Solution to a Big Problem in SLC

Big Dreams for Tiny Houses by Architectural Nexus in Salt Lake City

Babs DeLay: Utah’s Housing Market Suffers Under The Weight of California Migrants

Utah’s Unaffordable Housing

SUBSCRIBE TO PRINT MAGAZINE

Subscribe to Utah Stories weekly newsletter and get our stories directly to your inbox

Development Projects, Online Exclusives, Opinion, Utah Stories

Salt Lake City, tiny homes, zoning restrictions

Richard Markosian

I am a story teller and journalist. I have a passion for farmers, local craftspeople, and folks who aspire to create, build and grow their business in the local marketplace. Why local? By supporting locally-owned businesses we create more opportunity for entrepreneurs, and we claim our sovereignty to shape our communities how we want to see them. I aspire to build Utah Stories Magazine into a household Utah name, and assist Utah businesses and makers with marketing. On the journalism side of things my passion is investigative journalism that offers true insight into issues. I believe strongly in the forth estate: strong, meaningful, insightful journalism is essential to a free market Democracy.

Community Relations

Salt Lake City Newcomers Club: Finding Friendship and Belonging Since 1948

Moving away from your hometown can come with many blessings. But for some, it also comes with just as many bouts of loneliness. That ache of not knowing where to meet people, or grieving the friends you left behind, comes in waves. Workplaces and churches can sometimes provide ready-made communities, but what happens when they don’t? Where do you go to find true belonging?
Healthy Utah

A Stand-Up Wheelchair Gives Paralysis Patients Greater Independence

After a cycling accident left him paralyzed, Bill Winchester had to relearn how to navigate daily life from a wheelchair. A stand-up wheelchair later gave him the ability to rise, move more independently, and regain parts of the active life he once knew.
Podcast

Whiskey, Bullets & a Buried Town: Archaeologists Reveal Alta’s Wild Past

Before Alta was known for powder days and lift lines, it was a silver mining town clinging to the side of a narrow canyon. In the late 1800s, men lived at 8,000 feet, went underground each day, and endured winters that regularly buried buildings in snow. This past summer, that mining town resurfaced — literally — during construction at the Alta Ski Area.

To understand what Alta really looked like, you don’t begin with legend. You begin with its trash — and this time, that happened almost by accident.

Alta Ski Area was installing underground water reservoirs to support snowmaking. Because the project sits on Uinta-Wasatch-Cache National Forest land, an archaeologist was required to monitor the excavation. No one expected the trench to produce much.

But, It did.

Artifacts began surfacing almost immediately. Enough that the Forest Service contacted the Utah State Historic Preservation Office for help. Lexi Little, who coordinates the Utah Cultural Site Stewardship Program, helped mobilize nearly 30 volunteers to assist with what quickly became a focused two-week excavation.

Winter deadlines were approaching. The pipes for the reservoirs had to go in the ground. There wasn’t time for a slow, extended dig.

“It was two weeks of digging in the dirt and helping figure out exactly what we were looking at,” Little said.

Most of the people screening soil weren’t professional archaeologists. They were trained stewards from around Utah — part of a statewide volunteer network that now approaches 500 people. They poured dirt through shaker screens, scanning for fragments that could piece together a town long buried.

“Archaeology is human trash,” Little explained. “Archaeologists are very into trash.”

Alta had left plenty behind.

https://youtu.be/hzIHzx3OGoo?si=dKcl2CEz-t6FZzYw

Victorian-style ceramics appeared first — the kind typically used in hotels. Medicine bottles followed. Ink bottles. Hand-blown glass. A porcelain doll’s foot surfaced from the soil, a small detail that shifted the mental image of the town. Families were here. Children were here. This wasn’t only a camp of miners.

The bottles helped establish time. Manufacturing details — whether glass was hand-blown or mold-made, whether a maker’s mark appeared on the base — allowed archaeologists to date many of the artifacts to the 1870s through the 1890s, when Alta was booming as a silver mining town.

“That gives you that range of dates for when Alta was really booming,” Little said.

One reusable soda bottle clearly stamped “Salt Lake City” connected the canyon to the valley economy below.

Then something unusual rolled out of a dirt pile.

A corked bottle. Intact. Liquid still inside.

Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).
Podcast

How Horses Help Kids Heal: Inside Utah’s Equine Therapy World

Kelty Johnson trains horses for a living, but her deeper work happens in the quiet space between animal and human. On the Utah Stories podcast, she explains how equine therapy helps children regulate emotions, build confidence, and reconnect through presence rather than pressure.