Utah Stories

Homemade Lobster rolls

you can create really delicious lobster rolls at home. These would be a tasty addition to your Labor Day weekend.

|


 

Last week I wrote an article for Utah Bites about the terrific lobster rolls at Freshie’s. Well, with a little work and great ingredients (fresh lobster), you can create really delicious lobster rolls at home. These would be a tasty addition to your Labor Day weekend.

Ingredients for homemade Lobster rolls :

1 lb. cooked lobster meat (shelled)
1 small celery stick, minced (some people like to use cucumber)
2-3 tbsp. mayonnaise, to taste
1 tbsp. chopped fresh tarragon (dill is also commonly used)
1 tbsp. chopped chives or scallions
1 tsp. kosher salt
1 tsp. black pepper
4 New England-style hot dog buns (see note below*)
2 tbsp. unsalted butter
Fresh lemon juice
*A note about the buns: In New England, it’s de rigueur to use “top-loading” hot dog buns. These are buns that are sliced on the top, rather than the sides, allowing the lobster roll to stand upright — they’re typically served in a rectangular cardboard container. Pepperidge Farm makes a good top-loader bun, but I haven’t been able to find them here. So, I just buy unsliced hot dog buns.

Lobster roll method:

1. Remove the shells from 1-2 (depending on their size) cooked lobsters, saving the lobster meat.
2. Chop the lobster meat into chunky pieces, not too finely. You want to be able to see pieces of claw, tail, etc. Place the lobster meat into a large mixing bowl.
3. Using a spatula or large spoon, gently fold in the mayonnaise, celery, tarragon, chives, salt and pepper. I am very judicious in my use of mayo. I want to taste lobster, not mayonnaise. Use as much or as little mayo as you prefer. You can do this well ahead of serving time to allow the flavors to come together. Cover and refrigerate at least one hour until ready to assemble the rolls.
4. Using a paring knife, slice the bun tops open to make pockets for the lobster.
5. Melt one tablespoon of butter in a large, heavy skillet over medium heat. Then, toast the buns on three sides (excluding the top), adding the additional tablespoon of butter if the pan gets too dry, until they are a bit crisp and buttery, about 6-8 minutes.
6. Then, simply stuff the buns with the lobster mixture and enjoy, drizzled with fresh lemon juice. It’s common to serve lobster rolls with pickles and potato chips on the side.

FOR RESTAURANT REVIEWS GO HERE

THIS CONTENT IS FROM UTAH BITES NEWSLETTER.

GET OUR WEEKLY RESTAURANT REVIEWS, TED’S FAVORITE RECIPE AND DRINK OF THE WEEK DIRECTLY TO YOUR INBOX. TO SIGN UP FOR FREE GO HERE.

Originally trained as an anthropologist, Ted Scheffler is a seasoned food, wine & travel writer based in Utah. He loves cooking, skiing, and spends an inordinate amount of time tending to his ever-growing herd of guitars and amplifiers.

SUPPORT OUR SPONSORS: click on their logos to visit their website

 

[envira-gallery slug=”food-logos”]

, , , , ,


Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.


  • Salt Lake Food News: Gossip Kitchen Opens Downtown, Hand Roll Pop-Up, Cinco de Mayo Specials in Park City

    A new downtown restaurant blends Japanese tapas with Italian classics, a one-night hand roll pop-up lands in Sugar House, and Park City prepares for Cinco de Mayo with taco specials.


  • El Puerto in Sandy Brings Authentic Veracruz Cooking and a 3-Generation Mole to Utah

    Their culinary roots go back more than 30 years in Veracruz, where the restaurant tradition began with the grandmother, continued with the mother, and is now carried forward by the granddaughter.


  • The $7 Million Recruit: How NIL Changed College Athletics Forever

    In 2012, Jabari Parker, a top high school prospect and member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, was facing his biggest decision to that point in his life: where to play college basketball. 

    Fans of BYU athletics hoped and perhaps prayed that Parker would pick the school owned by the church he was raised in. BYU was listed as one of his final choices. But he ultimately chose to spend his college years at Duke before attempting a career in the NBA. BYU fans were disappointed, but no one was truly surprised. Duke over BYU was the best choice for a young prospect in 2012. 

    A.J. Dybantsa.

    What changed between 2012 and 2024 when A.J. Dybantsa, the number one high school prospect, chose BYU over every other school? The answer is roughly $7 million dollars. That is what Dybantsa is reportedly making to play basketball at BYU. 

    The deal was supported by Utah Jazz owner Ryan Smith, who met multiple times with the Dybantsa family in multiple attempts to bring the young player to Provo. 

    According to Smith, he had no financial role in bringing Dybantsa to BYU, but the influence of Utah’s most famous billionaire acting as a “booster” or unofficial recruiter certainly swayed the decision.

    Prior to 2021, boosters acting as recruiters was taboo to the NCAA governing body. It was called improper recruiting. But in 2021, California began the modern era of NIL, or the ability of a college athlete to benefit from their name, image, or likeness, when they passed the “Fair Pay to Play Act.” 

    This new law gave college athletes in California the ability to benefit from their NIL, something that was banned in the rest of the country to that point. The NCAA saw that this law would create an unfair advantage for California schools that could now give young athletes the chance to make money off their talent and image while still in college. 

    The NCAA knew they needed to do something quickly, so they rushed through a policy that opened up NIL to all college athletes in the country, and it has been expanding and evolving over the last four years. 

    Grant Duff, who has coached at the University of Utah, Weber State University, and is now the defensive coordinator for Idaho State University, says, “The best part of NIL is that athletes have an opportunity to make good money. The downside comes with the free-for-all that money causes.”

    Dybantsa confers with BYU Head coach, Kevin Young.

    One of the biggest current examples of what a school can do when the boosters are willing to pay for success is Texas Tech University. From 2020-2024, Texas Tech had 34 wins, which works out to 6.8 wins per year with a low of 4 wins and high of 8. Then Texas Tech’s boosters got involved, led by Cody Campbell, an oil industry businessman and Chairman of the Texas Tech board. The football program was given 28 million dollars for NIL with a simple message attached to the large pile of money: Win. And win now. And win they did. 

    By signing NIL deals with athletes in the transfer portal, Texas Tech went from a middle-of-the-pack school in their conference to one of the top 12 teams in the country. They didn’t just win games in 2025, they made many of their opponents look like they didn’t belong on the same field, including the University of Utah and BYU twice. That is what money can buy.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).


  • Cottonwood Heights Corruption Allegations: A Case That Never Reached a Courtroom

    A year ago, we here at Utah Stories recorded a podcast episode that we never published. We were revisiting corruption allegations from ten years ago. We decided not to publish the video, so it sat there on YouTube for nearly 12 months.

    Then somehow the video was published. How? We are not sure, but once it got out there, the comments came pouring in.

    Dozens of viewers, then hundreds, supported the video with their comments on our examination of allegations of police misconduct in Cottonwood Heights. The video recounts how the Police Department was reported by business owners as focusing enforcement on customers of the former Canyon Inn bar. These allegations did not result in a publicly documented, full investigation by Utah’s Justice Department nor the FBI (at least to our knowledge). So why rehash the past?

    We believe the story of The Canyon Inn (and other area business owners) vs. CHPD and Cottonwood Heights Mayor Kelvin Cullimore raises questions about what can happen when allegations surface and do not move forward through a formal legal process with state or federal oversight.

    In 2012, Cottonwood Heights business owners at the mouth of the canyons began publicly objecting to police activity whereby up to seven cruisers were pulling over 711 and Canyon Inn bar customers on their busiest evenings.

    According to those accounts, drivers leaving the bar were frequently pulled over by police and were given DUI tickets, sometimes even after passing a sobriety examination. The volume and concentration of those stops led residents and business owners to complain about the “heavy-handed treatment” of CHPD toward motorists, especially in and around the Canyon Inn and neighboring 711, and eventually the Porcupine Pub.

    Customers responded in predictable ways. Some chose not to return and avoid the area. Others went to different establishments. Over time, the owner of the Canyon Inn, Jim Stojack, stated that his revenue declined by 70% and that he believed police activity near his business was the main contributing factor.

    Utah Stories reported on these concerns by conducting interviews; gathering video documentation provided by those involved; and making public records requests. Through our GRAMA requests, we reviewed DUI citations issued by the Cottonwood Heights Police Department and examined how those cases were resolved in Holladay Justice Court. During that period, we observed a higher number based on our review of DUI cases dismissed in court due to lack of evidence compared to other jurisdictions. One DUI attorney, Tyler Ayers, went on record saying that CHPD was issuing a high volume of DUI citations that were later dismissed.

    That observation raised questions about how cases were being documented and prosecuted. It did not, on its own, establish intent or misconduct, but it became part of a broader set of concerns raised by multiple sources.

    Continue reading and support independent Utah journalism with a purchase of Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).