Debate

Report Used in Young Living Farms Case Against DoTERRA Suspect

Was the evidence that Young Living filed in a court case against doTERRA in 2013 fraudulent?

|


According to Dr. Robert Pappas (Founder of Essential Oil University) the report that Young Living Farms included in their case against doTERRA in 2013 does not appear to be conducted on oils that doTERRA sells. Dr. Pappas comes to this conclusion because the chemicals compounds listed in their findings appear nothing like the peppermint oil on which Dr. Pappas has conducted many tests.

Dr. Robert Pappas, image from story written by Indiana University in 2012.

Dr. Pappas  has his PhD in chemistry and has done consulting work in essential oils for nearly two decades. He said that the conclusions of the findings of their lavender oil and peppermint oils which are shown in the case filings nowhere indicate that the oils tested are in fact doTERRA oils. The chemical analysis was conducted by the Centre National De La Recherche Scientifique’s whose headquarters are located in Paris, France. Their conclusions were the following:

“For each sample, the composition is not in agreement with norm ISO/FDIS 856. Abnormal presence of ethyl vanillin (molecule of synthetic origin). Found on page 35 of their report. The samples they tested are listed as the following:

Peppermint 1118702
Peppermint 1225402
Peppermint 130311A”

Utah Stories will attempt in the coming days to contact both Young Living Farms and the CNRS for their comments on the findings found in the report.

This is a follow up story to the story written entitled, “Damning Evidence the Young Living and doTERRA’s Oils are Adulterated.”

, , , ,


Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.


  • Eight-Story Hotel at Sugar House’s Former Sizzler Site

    The long-vacant Sizzler lot in Sugar House is now at the center of a debate over an eight-story hotel proposal. After receiving a recommendation for approval from the Planning Commission, the project now heads to the Salt Lake City Council for a final decision.


  • Why Biblical Values Matter: Nephilim, Morality, and Israel’s Call

    In a world where truth shifts with the wind, the Bible offers a steady guide for navigating life’s big questions. Join a Utahn’s journey into scripture’s wisdom with Yoni Kayman, an Israeli rabbi who unravels mysteries like the Nephilim—ancient “giants” symbolizing power’s dangers. From Genesis to today’s moral debates, Kayman argues the Bible is our “user manual,” countering relativism with timeless values. He connects Abraham’s call to modern Israel’s struggles, urging us to choose justice over bias. For Utahns, from Provo’s faithful to Salt Lake’s skeptics, this exploration challenges us to anchor our communities in compassion and truth. Dive into a conversation that bridges ancient texts and today’s divides, revealing why biblical values still matter.


  • Can Regular Utahns Still Afford a Home?

    Utah’s housing market may feel out of reach, but realtor and former attorney Asha Klarich believes there are still clear pathways to homeownership. From first-time buyer grants and ADUs to zoning reform and smarter financing, she lays out practical steps for everyday Utahns to break into the market.


  • Utah’s Wine Loophole

    Most people assume Utah is the strictest state in the nation for alcohol. One small importer discovered the opposite—and uncovered a legal quirk that gives Utah more freedom than the rest of the country. Her journey explains how

    To access this post, you must purchase Utah Stories (Digital + Print) or 3 month free trial (Digital).