Utah Stories

Brother, Can you Spare a Twenty?

Is panhandling a way to earn a living? One journalist goes undercover to find out.

|


Utah Stories’ Al Sachrov Experiments with Panhandling

I was curious. It seems that at every intersection and interstate ramp in Salt Lake there are panhandlers. Mention that to a person and the urban myths abound – “They make thirty dollars an hour.” “They drive their Cadillacs to the job.” Et cetera. Et cetera.

I wanted to know what this job entails. So I did it. One cold morning I stood on a corner and depended upon the kindness of strangers. Nervously, I held out my sign – a generic “Anything Can Help. God Bless.” Drivers instantly averted their eyes. My smiling or waving did not matter. The only person who noted my presence was a little girl in an SUV. She waved back to me. However, I did see a lot of questionable driving behavior, including finishing breakfast, reading reports, applying make-up and one dog attempting to drive.

Then the cold set to work. My feet and back started to ache. After an hour it became painful. I decided to change my strategy. I held up a second sign that read, “Amateur brain surgeon seeks work or donations.” I thought that if people chuckled they might be more inclined to contribute.

I did get chuckles… and one donation. A driver smiled, shook his head, rolled down his window and handed me four quarters and a penny. Whereas before I felt as if I were a telephone pole, now I had a job. Granted, I was making less than a third-world textile worker, but at least somebody recognized my existence. I didn’t know if this was a good thing or not.

utah pandhandling

The one dollar could not buy much, but it did allow me to experience a fleeting moment of dignity. I could at least hope my fortunes would improve. If I had not been recognized, I would have probably gone off to a more productive endeavor such as collecting cans.

After two hours, I brought my experiment to a close. I draw no conclusions as to the reason people panhandle. I only observe that it is a hard and painful way to make a buck and a penny.

Utah Stories will be making a donation of $51.01 to the Utah Food Bank



Join our newsletter.
Stay informed.

Related Articles


  • The “Monster” of Bear Lake

    Have you ever heard of Utah’s hidden lake monsters? Beyond the tourist buzz of Bear Lake, whispers of a mysterious creature have persisted for generations. Dive into the untold stories, rare sightings, and eerie folklore surrounding Utah’s most elusive aquatic legend. Are the rumors real, or just a product of overactive imaginations?

    To access this post, you must purchase Full Access Membership.


  • Frisco, Utah: The Untold Story of the West’s Most Notorious Ghost Town

    Once a wild silver mining town, Frisco, Utah, was infamous for its nightly violence and lawless streets. Known as the “toughest mining town in the West,” its fortunes changed after a catastrophic mine collapse. Today, the deserted remains of Frisco, with its decaying kilns and empty streets, tell the story of a town that lived fast and died young. The mysteries of its vanished lawman and the outlaws who once ruled the streets still linger in its desolate landscape.

    To access this post, you must purchase Full Access Membership.


  • From Felon to Founder: How Rocky Rebuilt His Life After 12 Felony Convictions

    By the age of eight, Rocky was already using drugs, and by his twenties, he had 12 felony convictions and had spent years behind bars. His future seemed sealed. But then, something unexpected happened. Learn how Rocky defied the odds, escaped the cycle of addiction and crime, and turned his shattered life into a story of redemption and success.


  • Utah Book Bans Ignite Cultural Clash: Educator John Arthur on Local Control

    A battle over book bans is sweeping Utah’s schools, pitting state laws against local communities’ rights to shape education. Utah Teacher of the Year John Arthur steps into the fray, challenging restrictions that he believes rob students of vital perspectives and the freedom to explore. Are blanket bans the answer, or are we sacrificing young minds in a cultural clash?